This page deals with surgery for hammertoes. Visit here for details on the cause and conservative treatment for hammer toes. If you are considering hammertoe surgery, please read this page carefully. Although usually effective, hammertoe surgery has a lot of potential complications.

What is a Hammertoe?

Normally, the bones that make up the toes are straight. A hammertoe is a toe that is bent at the first joint of the toe. It can affect any of the the toes, although it is rare on the big toe. The bent toe can cause pain because the top of the toe hits the top of the shoe. This pressure can lead to a corn and/or to pain in the toe. In addition, hammertoes put pressure on the metatarsal bones and often cause pain under the ball of the foot.

Are Hammertoes More Common in Women?

Women are more likely to get hammertoes and be bothered by them because they wear smaller, tighter shoes that increase pressure on the toes.

How are Hammertoes Treated?

There are many effective non-surgical treatments for hammertoes. Read more about how a podiatrist can treat your hammertoes and about home treatments to relieve hammer toe pain.

Will Conservative Treatment Straighten a Hammertoe?

While we can usually relieve the pain of a hammertoe conservatively, no conservative treatment has been shown in studies to be effective at permanently straightening a hammertoe. The only way to permanently straighten the toe is through surgery.

What will happen if a Hammertoe is Left Alone?

Generally, hammertoes become worse over time. The bent toe often starts off flexible and eventually becomes stiff. This can cause increased pain both on top of the toe and on the ball of the foot.

How can a Hammertoe be Cured?

The only effective way of correcting the deformity is to have an operation. We still recommend that you try all conservative treatment before considering surgery, but in general the only way to cure a hammertoe is surgical correction.

How does a Hammertoe Operation Work to Correct the Deformity?

There are a number of different operations to treat hammertoes. The three most common hammertoe operations are tendon transfers, digital arthroplasty and digital arthrodesis

  • Tendon transfers involve taking the tendon under your toe and moving it to the top of the toe. This results in this tendon acting to pull the toe down into the ground instead of bending the toe. Sometimes this procedure is used alone and sometimes it is used in conjunction with the other two procedures. This hammertoe procedure can leave the toe a bit swollen and stiff.
  • Digital arthroplasty involves removing some of the bone from the bent joint. This allows the toe to straighten. An arthroplasty removes half the joint but leaves the joint with some motion.
  • Digtial Arthrodesis also involves removing bone from the joint, but once that is done the toe is fused in a straight and rigid position and there is no longer any motion in the toe joint.

In more severe cases, the tendon on the top of the toe along with the joint at the ball of the foot must be released to allow the toe to lie straight. In rare cases, where there is severe stiffness at this joint, then the base of the bone at the bottom of the toe (phalanx) may need to be removed (basal phalangectomy) or the metatarsal shortened (Weil osteotomy).

Which is the Best Surgery to Treat Hammertoes?

It depends on how much your toe is bent, how rigid your toe is and the biomechanics of your foot. Hammertoe surgery can be very complicated because everything that is done to one toe affects the pull of the muscles on the other toes. Dr. Hale is an exceptionally experienced hammertoe surgeon and will discuss the advantages and disadvantages of each procedure with you after examining your foot and your foot function.

Is Hammertoe Surgery Painful?

All surgery results in pain and swelling with the pain usually worse the night after surgery. Anaesthetic techniques and pain killers, however, allow this pain to be well controlled. In general, pain levels vary considerably from patient to patient with some experiencing no significant pain after hammertoe surgery.

Is a General Anesthetic Necessary for Hammertoe Surgery?

Usually not. Most patients are given a medication via IV to make them sleepy and then a local anesthetic is used. Most patients don’t even remember the procedure itself. We always ensure that the patient feels absolutely no pain during the surgery.

How Long is the Hospital Stay?

Most patients are able to have this type of operation performed as day surgery and go home. You are usually at the hospital only for a few hours.

Will a Cast be needed after Hammertoe Surgery?

Plaster casts are usually not required for toe surgery

Are There a Lot of Complications from Hammertoe Surgery?

Every surgery has potential risks and complications. Your surgeon will discuss the risks with you in detail prior to scheduling your surgery. With most foot surgery it is important to understand that that you may still have some pain and stiffness after surgery . It is also important to know that the deformity may reoccur in the future. This is why we recommend surgery only as a last resort after trying all conservative treatment for hammertoes first. If you have a hammertoe but do not have pain or any limitation in activity, we advise that you absolutely do not have surgery. NEVER have hammertoe surgery for purely cometic reasons. The potential for pain afterwards is too great.

We are very careful about making every effort to avoid any complication. Even so, complications can occur. General risks of any surgery include pain, swelling and infection. Some of the specific risks that can occur with toe surgery include:

  • Long lasting swelling of the toe. This can even be permanent.
  • Return of the deformity or a corn on the toe
  • Regrowth of removed bone
  • Continued pain in the toe
  • A floppy toe
  • A Stiff toe
  • The toe may not be able to reach the ground (this is called a “floating toe” and is more common with the arthrodesis procedure)
  • Pain in other parts of your foot during the recovery period. In general, but not always, this goes away with time.
  • A mallet toe deformity may develop over time

When Can a Patient Walk Again and Wear Shoes After Hammertoe Surgery?

Most of the time, you will able to walk using crutches three or four days after toe surgery, but you will remain somewhat limited for about 2 weeks. To keep swelling down we may keep you on crutches after a hammer toe operation for a longer period of time.

Some patients can start wearing wider shoes after 2 weeks with about 60% in shoes at six weeks and 90% in 8 weeks. Arthrodesis procedures take longer to heal and shoes cannot be worn until any wire or pin that is used to support the surgery site has been removed. In general this is about three to six weeks.

Swelling usually starts to decrease around six to eight weeks and the foot will be beginning to feel close to normal at about three months. The entire healing process, however, continues for about one year.

How Long After Hammertoe Surgery Until You Can Drive?

Not until you feel able to perform an emergency stop. In general, this is somewhere between one to two months after surgery. We suggest you also check with your auto insurance company to see if they have any rules regarding foot surgery and driving.

How Long Until A Hammertoe Surgery Patient Can return to Work?

If you are able to get ride to and from work and your job is not active and you can elevate your foot, you may be able to return to work a week or two after toe surgery. In general, patients who must be on their feet at work return to work between four to eight weeks after the procedure depending on the type of job, how active you are and response to surgery.

How Long Until Hammertoe Surgery Patients can return to Athletics?

Although healing continues for up to one year, most patients are able to return to relatively intense athletic activity at around three months. This will depend on the type of surgery you have and how your response to surgery.

How do you Find the Best Hammertoe Surgeon?

Like everything else, some foot surgeons are exceptionally skilled at hammertoe surgery; some are quite bad at it and most are somewhere in-between. To ensure the best chance of a good outcome, it is critical that you find an exceptionally skilled and experienced hammertoe surgeon. On our page on bunion surgery, we outline a number of items to look for in identifying good surgeons and also how to identify surgeons you should avoid. You can find surgeon evaluation information here.

Click Here For Self Treatment Hints